China Translated

Second quarter growth in China’s FX reserves was a tiny USD7bln, despite more than a USD40bln addition from the trade surplus.  Slight growth in reserves despite the robust trade surplus suggests hot money was flowing out of China in the last two months of the quarter.

Two years of stability in the exchange rate knocked hot money off the policy agenda for the government: with little chance of yuan appreciation there was less reason for speculators to bring capital into the country.  But the recent announcement of the next stage in exchange rate reform will bring hot money back into vogue. 

Either appreciation against the dollar will be rapid and one way and the result will be increased incentives to bring hot money into the country - providing the real estate and equity markets pull themselves together.  Or appreciation will be faltering with the possibility of two way volatility - in which case speculators will probably find somewhere else to park their cash.

The interest in hot money in China’s policy circles is partly a relic of the Asian financial crisis, and, to a lesser extent, the speculative attack which forced the British pound to crash out of the European Rate Mechanism in the early 1990s. 

Chinese policy markers were horrified by the ability of foreign speculators to bring the governments of Asian neighbours to their knees, and by the humiliation at the hands of the IMF and its austerity programmes that followed. 

China has a closed capital account, so the chances of a similar attack are slight.  But that does not stop the Chinese media worrying about attacks by ‘big financial crocodiles’ (金融大锷 jinrong da e) - as George Soros style currency speculators are referred to.

This is my translation of a short section from a recent SAFE Q&A on the subject:

‘Our investigations in the first half of the year reveal that the vast majority of capital flows were legal and legitimate.  We have not discovered any large organised attempts to circumvent capital controls.  Most hot money is brought into the country through small transactions. 

As for so called ‘big financial crocodiles’, as we still have controls on capital account transations,  any speculative attack would be illegal - and this means that hedge funds and other financial institutions would think twice before trying their luck.

Hot money mainly enters the country disguised as legitimate trade and investment flows.  There are many and various routes.  But typically speculators are not particularly skilled at disguising hot money flows, so it is not that hard to pick up the signs of irregular transactions: 

-Companies in the processing trade will often under price inputs and over price outputs - with the collusion of their customers - to bring hot money into the country. 

-Shipping companies will take payments early and make payments late to increase their holdings of foreign capital. 

-Service companies can charge foreign customers for transport or consultancy services that are never provided, in order to have an excuse to bring hot money into the country. 

-Foreign investment is often disguised hot money, with investment advisory companies playing the role of broker for foreigners who want to make investments in the real estate or equity markets.’

You can see SAFE’s statement here.

Exchange rate, IFIs, Investment, Monetary Policy, Property, Stocks, Trade